Falsehoods and Fabulous Trends

In the most recent unit on persuasive writing, my class has had to explore various terminology related to persuasion.  Such terms as proposition, evidence, evaluation, testimonials, and bandwagon appeal have been discussed.  It is one of my favorite units, because I get to teach not only writing techniques that help my students create plausible arguments (such as why their parents should finally cave in and by them a puppy), but also critical thinking skills that will help them develop better choices in the real world.

I get to crush my poor students’ perfect world where TV ads are all true and fashion is new, to help them see the world in a broken, manipulative, and colorful light.  I have two lessons that perspicuously demonstrate the finer points of our consumer choices.

1. Testimonials

Kids are suckers for celebs.  If a famous person endorses a product, it has to be true.  Without fail, I am always able to find some unsuspecting young jock wearing a Power Balance bracelet, convinced that it works.  I mean, if Shaquille O’Neal can almost incomprehensibly mumble his way to a product’s endorsement, it’s legit, right?  I mean, he even gets to the “scientific” part!

They love it and believe it, until I show them how it “works”.

I don’t actually show them the second video, but I do the same demonstration with students using, not a Power Balance Band, but a Power Balance Lamb, and let their jaws hit the floor. I confess I enjoy seeing my students with a Power Balance Band look down at their cheap rubber bracelets in shame.

All that is to say— just because a celeb. endorses it, doesn’t mean it’s worth it.

2. Bandwagon Appeal

In making the point about bandwagon appeal and how people are all after the hot new item, I appealed to the trends that Generation Z kids currently embrace:

Rubber Band Bracelets
five-below-hot-trend-rubber-band-bracelet-kits

Colorful Skinny Jeans

f21-skinnies

Silly Mustaches
mustache

Ridiculous Socks

nike-elite-basketball-crew-socks-mens

To be fair, I had to share with the kids the trends that I grew up with, items that were all the rage.  Oh, how the wagon has rolled because we had…

Slap Bracelets
mp_large.

Colorful Skinny Jeans

versace-circa-early-90s-models-christy.jpeg?w=500&h=706

Silly Mustaches

mustache tom-selleck

Ridiculous Socks

leg-warmers

Full Circle

Well, it looks like things have come full circle.  In fact, what made me think of this was that today one of my sweet students came into my classroom and presented me with a brand new…

…slap bracelet.

photo

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Falsehoods and Fabulous Trends

  1. An interesting take on the persuasive writing units. I have this to teach soon, I might steal a few of these ideas.
    Thanks for following my blog.

  2. I think this is a great way to tackle persuasive writing units. Everyone, especially middle school students can get suckered into the latest “fabs” so this will also be a great way to show students the persuasive techniques used by companies.

  3. Pingback: Educator Blogging: What Do the Teachers Have to Say? – SLM508CNC: Corey Clark's Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s